Politics · October 28, 2026
Peltola denies NYT report her campaign recruited other Sullivan

Recent reports have surfaced alleging that the campaign of Democratic Senate candidate Mary Peltola and national Democratic operatives were involved in recruiting a Republican candidate, Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., to run against incumbent Republican Sen. Dan S. Sullivan. The New York Times, citing multiple sources and internal communications, described a 'ballot composition project' intended to siphon votes from the incumbent by introducing a candidate with a similar name. While the Peltola campaign and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee (DSCC) have officially denied involvement, a former campaign manager reportedly confirmed awareness of the effort. The Department of Justice is currently investigating the candidacy, and President Trump has called for Peltola's withdrawal and prosecution, characterizing the move as election interference.
Read the original coverage
Trump Calls for Mary Peltola, Alaska Senate Candidate, to Be Prosecuted
Read at The New York Times ↗Trump called for Democratic former Rep. Mary Peltola to be criminally prosecuted and removed from the ballot in the Alaska Senate race
Read at Wall Street Journal ↗Report on recruiting a ‘spoiler’ shakes up Senate race in Alaska
Read at Washington Post ↗- CNNAllSides: Lean Left (Digital)MBFC: Left-Center
A new report confirms Democrats were behind the Dan Sullivan spoiler candidacy. Will it matter?
Read at CNN ↗ - The HillMBFC: Least Biased
Peltola denies NYT report her campaign recruited other Sullivan
Read at The Hill ↗ - Fox NewsAllSides: Right (Digital)MBFC: Right
Peltola campaign's alleged Dan Sullivan spoiler plot takes new turn as DOJ faces major legal hurdle
Read at Fox News ↗ - NBC NewsMBFC: Left-Center
Bombshell report rocks Alaska Senate race
Read at NBC News ↗ - ABC NewsMBFC: Left-Center
Peltola campaign under fire after report that it recruited second Dan Sullivan for Alaska Senate race
Read at ABC News ↗ - CBS NewsMBFC: Right-Center
Democrats pushed to get second Dan Sullivan on Alaska ballot with Peltola's help, NYT reports
Read at CBS News ↗ Trump Calls for Peltola to Be Banned From Alaska Senate Race
Read at Bloomberg ↗- The GuardianMBFC: Left-Center
Democrat Mary Peltola’s campaign reportedly recruited second Dan Sullivan in Alaska Senate race
Read at The Guardian ↗ - New York PostAllSides: Right (News)MBFC: Right-Center
Mary Peltola ‘definitely aware’ Dems searched for another Dan Sullivan to confuse voters in Alaska race: bombshell report
Read at New York Post ↗ - Washington ExaminerMBFC: Right-Center
Mary Peltola allies accused of recruiting ‘Decoy Dan’ as DOJ inquiry continues
Read at Washington Examiner ↗ - Washington TimesMBFC: Right-Center
Peltola allies recruited spoiler candidates in Alaska Senate race: Report
Read at Washington Times ↗ - The Daily WireMBFC: Right
God, Gender, And A Senate Race Headed For Holy Hell
Read at The Daily Wire ↗ - Just the NewsMBFC: Far Right
Peltola campaign recruited 2nd Dan Sullivan to spoil Senate race: NYT
Read at Just the News ↗ - NewsweekMBFC: Right-Center
Alaska's Two Dan Sullivans Controversy Just Got More Complicated
Read at Newsweek ↗ - BreitbartMBFC: Right
Report: Alaska Democrats Made Plan to Find Second Dan Sullivan Candidate
Read at Breitbart ↗ - PBS NewsMBFC: Left-Center
WATCH: Trump calls for Peltola to drop out after report her campaign helped recruit 2nd Dan Sullivan
Read at PBS News ↗ - ReasonMBFC: Right-Center
To Confuse Voters, Mary Peltola's Campaign Recruited a Second Dan Sullivan
Read at Reason ↗ - TheBlazeMBFC: Right
NY Times exposes Alaska Democrat's alleged hunt for another Dan Sullivan to run against Republican
Read at TheBlaze ↗ - NewsNationMBFC: Right-Center
Peltola denies report her campaign worked to recruit another 'Dan Sullivan'
Read at NewsNation ↗ - Financial TimesMBFC: Least Biased
Republicans seek to deflect Epstein anger on to Democrats
Read at Financial Times ↗ - SlateMBFC: Left
Will Alaska Democrats’ Dirty Tricks Cost the Party a Senate Seat?
Read at Slate ↗ - Washington Free BeaconMBFC: Right
New York Times Increasingly Relies on Left-Wing Nonprofit Journalism
Read at Washington Free Beacon ↗ - The Epoch TimesMBFC: Right-Center
Peltola Campaign, Senate Democrats Deny Report That They Recruited Spoiler Candidates in Alaska Senate Race
Read at The Epoch Times ↗ - HuffPostMBFC: Left
Trump Demands Mary Peltola Be Taken Off Alaska Senate Race Ballot After NYT Report
Read at HuffPost ↗
Reported across the spectrum
- A New York Times report alleges the Mary Peltola campaign and Democratic operatives recruited a second Dan Sullivan to run in the Alaska Senate race.
- The second candidate is Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a Republican.
- The incumbent is Republican Sen. Dan S. Sullivan.
- The Peltola campaign has officially denied involvement in the recruitment of the second Sullivan.
- President Trump responded to the report by calling for Peltola to drop out of the race.
- The Department of Justice is looking into the candidacy of the second Dan Sullivan.
Reported by only some outlets
- The New York Times report is based on 12 sources, text messages, and internal documents.
- Former Peltola campaign manager Elisa Rios stated the candidate was aware of the recruitment effort but not personally involved.
- The effort was internally referred to as the 'ballot composition project.'
- Operatives reportedly sought other potential spoiler candidates beyond the second Sullivan.
- Daniel J. Sullivan Jr. qualified for the ballot by finishing in the top four during the August primary.
Left-leaning outlets tend to emphasize…
emphasize the Peltola campaign's denials and question the potential effectiveness or strategic logic of the recruitment effort, while characterizing the story as an 'October surprise.'
Right-leaning outlets tend to emphasize…
portray the effort as a 'secret' and deceptive 'scheme' to 'spoil' the election, highlighting allegations of 'voter fraud' and 'fake candidates' intended to confuse the electorate.
Centrist outlets tend to focus on…
focus on the specific findings of the investigative report and the resulting calls for accountability or prosecution from political opponents.
Where coverage diverges
Coverage diverges along left/right lines — see Framing tab for specifics.
FreeDaily Brief newsletter
Get the 5-minute Daily Brief, with the topics you pick.
The Daily Brief is free
About these outlets
- Just the NewsMBFC: Far Right
- The HillMBFC: Least Biased
- The Washington TimesMBFC: Right-Center
- Washington ExaminerMBFC: Right-Center
- NewsweekMBFC: Right-Center
- Fox NewsAllSides: Right (Digital)MBFC: Right
- BreitbartMBFC: Right
- ABC NewsMBFC: Left-Center
- PBS NewsMBFC: Left-Center
- ReasonMBFC: Right-Center
- TheBlazeMBFC: Right
- The GuardianMBFC: Left-Center
- NewsNationMBFC: Right-Center
- New York PostAllSides: Right (News)MBFC: Right-Center
- Financial TimesMBFC: Least Biased
- BloombergAllSides: CenterMBFC: Left-Center
- The Daily WireMBFC: Right
- SlateMBFC: Left
- The Wall Street JournalAllSides: Center (News)MBFC: Right-Center
- Washington Free BeaconMBFC: Right
- The Epoch TimesMBFC: Right-Center
- CBS NewsMBFC: Right-Center
- NBC NewsMBFC: Left-Center
- The New York TimesAllSides: Lean Left (News)MBFC: Left-Center
- The Washington PostAllSides: Lean Left (News)MBFC: Left-Center
- HuffPostMBFC: Left
- CNNAllSides: Lean Left (Digital)MBFC: Left-Center
CadNews does not determine absolute truth or endorse political viewpoints. It compares publicly available reporting, identifies shared facts, highlights framing differences, and flags uncertainty.
